Discharge Plea Without Bail & Exemption From Appearance Under Section 355 BNSS
Back to articles

Criminal Law

Discharge Plea Without Bail & Exemption From Appearance Under Section 355 BNSS

10 min readUpdated for the BNSS, 2024By Advocate Shailender Singh, Lucknow

Two questions trouble almost every accused person the moment a criminal case is registered against them: do I have to secure bail before I can challenge the very existence of the case, and must I attend every hearing in person? The law draws a clear distinction between seeking discharge and seeking bail, and it separately allows an accused to seek exemption from personal appearance. In a recent observation reported by Live Law, the Allahabad High Court has reiterated that a discharge plea can be filed without the accused first obtaining bail, and that the accused may seek exemption from personal appearance under Section 355 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023. This guide by a criminal lawyer in Lucknow explains the distinction, the procedural limits, and the case law that governs both propositions.

Discharge and bail are two different questions

Bail and discharge serve entirely different purposes in a criminal case. Bail is about the liberty of the accused while the case is pending — it secures release from custody or protects against arrest, on conditions, until the matter concludes. Discharge, by contrast, is a substantive challenge to the existence of the case itself: it asks the court to find that, even accepting the prosecution's case at face value, there is no sufficient ground to proceed against the accused, so that the accused is released from the proceedings without undergoing a full trial.

Because the two remedies answer different questions, one is not a precondition for the other. An accused does not have to first obtain bail in order to move a discharge application. A discharge application can be filed at the appropriate stage of the proceedings regardless of whether the accused is on bail, in custody, or has not yet furnished bail bonds. Conversely, being on bail does not prevent an accused from filing a discharge application — it simply means the question of liberty is already addressed while the question of whether a case exists at all is separately considered.

Can a discharge application be filed without first obtaining bail?

Yes. The right to seek discharge is a stage in the criminal proceedings, not a benefit contingent on first securing bail. The discharge provisions — Section 250 of the BNSS (formerly Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973) for cases before the Court of Session, and the corresponding Magisterial discharge provisions (formerly Sections 239 and 245 CrPC) for warrant cases — are triggered once the court has taken cognizance and the matter reaches the stage at which charge is to be considered. At that stage, the accused may press a discharge application on the ground that the material on record does not disclose a case to proceed.

In a recent observation reported by Live Law, the Allahabad High Court has reiterated precisely this proposition — that a discharge plea can be filed without the accused first obtaining bail, and that the accused may seek exemption from personal appearance under Section 355 BNSS. This is consistent with a settled line of authority holding that the court's power to dispense with an accused's personal attendance is not tied to the prior execution of bail bonds.

V.S. Reddy v. Excel Glasses Ltd. and Ors. (Kerala High Court, 2010)

The clearest authority on the point is V.S. Reddy v. Excel Glasses Ltd. and Ors. (MANU/KE/1367/2010), where the Kerala High Court set aside a Magistrate's order dismissing an accused's application for exemption from personal appearance on the ground that the accused had not appeared in person and that personal attendance was required to obtain bail. The High Court held: "Having gone through the above provisions, I fail to find that the accused can apply for exemption from personal attendance only after executing a bail bond. Even before executing a bail bond, in the event there are sufficient reasons, the accused is entitled to apply for exemption from personal appearance."

The High Court further held that in appropriate cases the Magistrate can allow an accused to make even the first appearance through counsel, and that the Magistrate ought to have considered the exemption application on its merits irrespective of the fact that the accused had not executed a bail bond. The reasoning applies with equal force to a discharge application: the ability to move the court on the merits of the case is not gated behind the prior furnishing of bail. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

The discharge provisions under the BNSS

Under the BNSS, discharge is considered at a defined procedural stage. In a case triable by the Court of Session, after the charge has been considered and the accused has been heard, the court may discharge the accused under Section 250 BNSS (corresponding to Section 227 CrPC) if it considers the accusation groundless. In warrant cases triable by a Magistrate, the corresponding discharge provisions (formerly Sections 239 and 245 CrPC) apply — one set for cases instituted on a police report and another for cases instituted on a private complaint, the latter typically arising after the recording of prosecution evidence.

A successful discharge application brings the proceedings against the accused to an early end without a full trial. Because it is a substantive determination that no case is made out, it is independent of the question of bail: the court examines the material on record to decide whether a case to proceed exists at all, not whether the accused has secured bail.

Exemption from personal appearance under Section 355 BNSS

Section 355 of the BNSS, 2023 (corresponding to Section 317 of the CrPC, 1973) deals with the power of the court to proceed with an inquiry or trial in the absence of the accused. It provides that at any stage of an inquiry or trial, if the Judge or Magistrate is satisfied, for reasons to be recorded, that the personal attendance of the accused before the court is not necessary in the interests of justice — or that the accused persistently disturbs the proceedings — the court may, if the accused is represented by a pleader, dispense with the accused's attendance and proceed with the inquiry or trial in the accused's absence, and may at any subsequent stage of the proceedings direct the personal attendance of the accused.

Two features of Section 355 BNSS must be understood clearly. First, it is a power of dispensation with personal attendance in appropriate proceedings — it does not itself grant bail, and it does not guarantee exemption. The grant of exemption is discretionary, and the court must record reasons for it. Second, the BNSS adds an Explanation that was absent in the CrPC: for the purposes of the section, the "personal attendance" of the accused includes attendance through audio-video electronic means. This recognises virtual appearance as a form of attendance, but it remains within the court's discretion and is subject to the conditions the court considers fit.

Crucially, the provision expressly preserves the court's ability to require personal attendance at any subsequent stage. Exemption granted at one stage is not permanent or absolute; the court may direct the accused to appear in person when the interests of justice require it — for example, at the framing of charge, during the recording of the accused's statement, or for identification and cross-examination. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

Landmark case law on exemption from appearance

Bhaskar Industries Ltd. v. Bhiwani Denim and Apparels Ltd. and Ors., (2001) 7 SCC 628

The foundational authority is Bhaskar Industries Ltd. v. Bhiwani Denim and Apparels Ltd. and Ors. (MANU/SC/0489/2001), in which the Supreme Court held that a Magistrate can dispense with the personal appearance of an accused either throughout or at any particular stage of the proceedings in a summons case. The Court observed that "it is within the powers of a magistrate and in his judicial discretion to dispense with the personal appearance of an accused either throughout or at any particular stage of such proceedings in a summons case, if the magistrate finds that insistence of his personal presence would itself inflict enormous suffering or tribulations to him, and the comparative advantage would be less." The Court cautioned that such discretion should be exercised only in rare instances — such as where the accused resides or carries on business at a great distance, or on account of physical or other good reasons — and that the Magistrate granting the benefit must take appropriate precautions.

Larsen and Toubro Ltd. v. Anand Bangad and Ors. (Madhya Pradesh High Court, 2002)

In Larsen and Toubro Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. v. Anand Bangad and Ors. (MANU/MP/1056/2002), the Madhya Pradesh High Court set aside a Sessions Court order and allowed the accused to appear through their pleader or counsel, while directing them to appear before the Trial Court for the limited purpose of executing bail bonds and personal bonds. Relying on Bhaskar Industries (supra), the High Court considered that the accused were based in Mumbai and that requiring them to travel to Ujjain for every hearing would lead to loss of work and money — a loss not only to the citizen but to the country. The decision illustrates the balanced approach courts adopt: personal attendance may be dispensed with for routine hearings, while the court may still require the accused's presence for specific procedural steps such as executing bail bonds.

Read together, these authorities establish that the power to dispense with personal attendance is not confined to a particular stage of the proceedings and is not contingent on the accused having first appeared in person or furnished bail bonds. The recent Allahabad High Court observation reported by Live Law — that a discharge plea can be filed without obtaining bail and that exemption may be sought under Section 355 BNSS — sits squarely within this established line of authority. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

The court's discretion, conditions, and limits

Exemption from personal appearance is a discretionary relief, and the court's discretion is guided by several principles drawn from the statute and the case law:

  • The accused must be represented by a pleader; the court cannot dispense with personal attendance of an unrepresented accused in the ordinary course.
  • The court must be satisfied, for reasons to be recorded, that personal attendance is not necessary in the interests of justice.
  • Exemption is typically reserved for genuine grounds — great distance, age, infirmity, professional or business hardship, or other good reasons — not as a matter of course.
  • The court may impose conditions, such as requiring the accused to appear on specific dates or for specific stages of the proceedings.
  • Exemption granted at one stage does not prevent the court from directing personal attendance at any subsequent stage when the interests of justice require it.
  • Exemption under Section 355 BNSS does not amount to bail and does not dispense with the requirement to furnish bail bonds where the offence and the stage of proceedings demand it.

The distinction matters: an accused may be exempt from routine personal appearance while still being required to execute bail bonds, or to attend for the framing of charge and the recording of their statement. Exemption and bail address different concerns, and a court may grant one without dispensing with the other. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

Practical steps for an accused in Lucknow

  • Engage a criminal defence advocate at the earliest, so that the discharge application is filed at the correct procedural stage with the right grounds.
  • Where personal attendance is a hardship, move a written application under Section 355 BNSS seeking exemption, setting out the specific grounds (distance, occupation, health, or other good reasons).
  • Ensure that a pleader or counsel is present on every date of hearing so that the precondition for dispensation is met.
  • Comply with any conditions the court imposes, including appearance on specified dates or for specified stages such as framing of charge.
  • Be prepared to attend in person whenever the court directs, particularly for the recording of the accused's statement under the BNSS.
  • Preserve all documents and correspondence that support both the discharge application and the grounds for exemption.

Disciplined, timely representation — filing the discharge application at the right stage and moving a properly grounded exemption application — protects both the accused's liberty and the accused's ability to challenge the case on its merits. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

General legal information, not legal advice

This article is intended to provide general legal information about the distinction between discharge and bail, and about exemption from personal appearance under Section 355 BNSS. It is not legal advice, and no advocate can guarantee a particular outcome. Whether a discharge application can be filed at a given stage, and whether exemption from personal appearance will be granted, depends on the specific facts of the case, the offence alleged, the stage of the proceedings, and the orders of the court seized of the matter. The propositions discussed here — including the recent Allahabad High Court observation reported by Live Law — must be applied to your circumstances with the assistance of a qualified criminal lawyer.

If you are facing a criminal case in Lucknow and wish to explore a discharge application or seek exemption from personal appearance, speak to a criminal defence advocate without delay. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.

Need legal help in Lucknow?

Speak with Advocate Shailender Singh.

Confidential, experienced representation before the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), Family Court and UP-RERA. Discuss your matter today.

Shailender Singh, Advocate
Chat on WhatsApp

© 2026 Shailender Singh, Advocate. All rights reserved.