A marriage may be dead in fact long before the law will call it dead. Indian matrimonial law, under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, dissolves a marriage only on proof of a statutory fault — cruelty, adultery, desertion and the like — or by mutual consent. Irretrievable breakdown, the simple fact that a marriage has collapsed beyond repair, is not a ground on which an ordinary family court can grant divorce. Yet the Supreme Court, exercising its extraordinary power under Article 142 of the Constitution, has dissolved marriages on exactly that basis. This article examines the gap between Section 13 and Article 142, the precedents that define it, and the crucial distinction between what the Supreme Court can do and what a family court cannot.
The statutory fault framework: Section 13 of the HMA
Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 sets out the grounds on which a Hindu marriage can be dissolved by a decree of divorce. The principal grounds are adultery, cruelty, desertion for a continuous period of not less than two years, conversion to another religion, and unsoundness of mind or mental disorder of a specified kind. Section 13B, inserted in 1976, added mutual consent divorce — a route by which both spouses jointly seek dissolution after a year of separation.
Two features of this framework are central to the breakdown debate. First, every ground under Section 13(1) is a fault ground: the petitioner must prove a matrimonial wrong by the other spouse. Second, irretrievable breakdown — the objective collapse of the marital relationship, with no reasonable prospect of reconciliation — is conspicuously absent from the list. A spouse whose marriage has simply died, without cruelty or desertion or adultery provable to the court's satisfaction, and who cannot obtain the other spouse's consent, has no statutory route to divorce.
Why breakdown was not made a ground
The framers of the Act were aware of irretrievable breakdown as a proposed ground. The Law Commission of India, in early reports, and the Marriage Laws committees, considered and debated it. The decision to omit it reflected a deliberate caution: that recognising breakdown might weaken the institution of marriage, that it could be invoked opportunistically, and that the financial position of the dependent spouse — usually the wife — required protection before a marriage could be ended on a no-fault basis. The result is a statute that treats marriage as dissolvable only for proven fault or genuine consent.
That caution has a cost. Where one spouse is determined to obstruct a divorce — refusing consent, denying fault, and dragging out litigation — the other can be trapped in a marriage that has long ceased to function, sometimes for years. It is this cost that the Supreme Court's Article 142 jurisdiction has been called on to address.
Article 142: the Supreme Court's plenary power
Article 142(1) of the Constitution empowers the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction, to pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing "complete justice" in any cause or matter pending before it. The Court has read this as a residuary, plenary power to craft relief that the strict letter of the law does not provide — but always within limits: it cannot contravene substantive statutory provisions or the Constitution, and it operates only in matters already before the Court.
In the matrimonial context, Article 142 has been invoked to dissolve marriages that the HMA's fault framework could not reach — marriages that had broken down irretrievably, where continued cohabitation was impossible and there was no realistic prospect of reconciliation. The power is extraordinary precisely because it does what Section 13 does not: it grants divorce on the ground of breakdown alone.
Naveen Kohli v. Neelu Kohli (2006): breakdown recognised in principle
In Naveen Kohli v. Neelu Kohli, (2006) 4 SCC 558, a three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court dissolved a marriage under Article 142 on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, after finding that the parties had levelled serious allegations against each other, lived apart for years, and that the marriage had "broken down irretrievably". The Court observed that where a marriage has broken down beyond repair, to insist on its continuance causes cruelty to both parties, and recommended that the legislature consider incorporating irretrievable breakdown as an independent ground of divorce.
Two things must be distinguished in Naveen Kohli. The dissolution itself was an exercise of Article 142 — a remedy available to the Supreme Court in the matter before it. The recommendation that breakdown be made a statutory ground was addressed to Parliament, and Parliament has not, to date, enacted it. Naveen Kohli therefore recognised breakdown as a basis for the Supreme Court's Article 142 power; it did not add breakdown to Section 13.
Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 544: the boundaries defined
The most authoritative recent statement is Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 544, a two-judge Bench decision that carefully demarcated the Article 142 power. The Court held that the power to dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown is exercisable by the Supreme Court under Article 142, and that it should be used sparingly, in exceptional circumstances, after considering the welfare of the parties and of any children, the financial position of the spouses, and whether the marriage has truly broken down beyond repair.
Critically, the Court drew the line that defines this entire field: the power to dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown is not available to the High Courts under Article 226, nor to the family courts or other subordinate courts. Only the Supreme Court, under Article 142, can grant such a divorce. The reason is constitutional: Article 142 is a special, plenary power vested in the Supreme Court alone, and it cannot be devolved downwards to courts of ordinary jurisdiction.
The distinction that matters: Supreme Court relief vs family court authority
This is the heart of the matter for any litigant. A spouse before the Family Court in Lucknow, or before the Allahabad High Court in an appeal, cannot obtain a divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown simpliciter. Those courts are bound by Section 13: they must find a statutory fault, or a valid mutual consent petition, before they can dissolve the marriage. If the only basis is breakdown — however complete — the petition must fail in those forums.
Only when the matter reaches the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its Article 142 jurisdiction, can breakdown alone justify dissolution. And even there, the Court has stressed restraint: it will not dissolve a marriage merely because the parties ask, but only where the breakdown is established, reconciliation is impossible, and complete justice demands it. The Supreme Court has also indicated that, where appropriate, it may mould relief — for instance, by ensuring the dependent spouse's financial interests are protected — rather than granting a bare dissolution. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.
The practical consequences
- A spouse trapped in a dead marriage without provable fault or mutual consent cannot get relief from the family court on breakdown alone; the statutory route is closed.
- The Article 142 route is available only in the Supreme Court, typically after the matter has travelled through the trial and appellate stages, or where the Supreme Court agrees to entertain a petition directly in exceptional circumstances.
- Even in the Supreme Court, dissolution on breakdown is discretionary and sparingly granted, with attention to the parties' welfare, children, and finances.
- The legislature has not amended Section 13 to include breakdown, despite judicial recommendations; the gap between statute and Article 142 therefore persists.
For most litigants, the realistic strategy is therefore to pursue the statutory grounds that are available — cruelty, desertion, or mutual consent where it can be secured — and to preserve the record of breakdown (long separation, failed mediation, irreconcilable differences) in case the matter ultimately reaches the Supreme Court. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.
General legal information, not legal advice
This article provides general legal information about the relationship between Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act and Article 142 of the Constitution. It is not legal advice. Whether a particular marriage can be dissolved depends on the facts, the forum, and the grounds available — matters that must be assessed by a qualified family law advocate. The distinction drawn here between the Supreme Court's Article 142 power and the authority of ordinary family courts is settled by Shilpa Sailesh (2023) and must be respected in any matrimonial strategy.
If you are facing a matrimonial matter in Lucknow and wish to understand your options under the Hindu Marriage Act, consult a family court advocate without delay. Book a confidential consultation with Advocate Shailender Singh in Lucknow.
Related reading:
Related services:
Need legal help in Lucknow?
Speak with Advocate Shailender Singh.
Confidential, experienced representation before the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), Family Court and UP-RERA. Discuss your matter today.



