A petition under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 asks the Family Court to direct a spouse who has withdrawn from the marriage to return. It is often filed in response to a maintenance claim, so the practical question is what the decree does, and does not do, to the other spouse's rights.
What Section 9 requires
The petitioner must show that the respondent has withdrawn from the society of the petitioner, that the withdrawal is without reasonable excuse, and that there is no other legal ground to refuse relief. By the Explanation to Section 9, the burden of proving a reasonable excuse lies on the spouse who has withdrawn. Cruelty, dowry demands, ill-treatment or a miscarriage met with neglect are the kind of facts raised as reasonable excuse.
Constitutional validity and execution
Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Smt. Saroj Rani v. Sudarshan Kumar Chadha, (1984) 4 SCC 90 : AIR 1984 SC 1562 (8 August 1984, Sabyasachi Mukharji and S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, JJ.) upheld Section 9 against challenge under Articles 14 and 21, approving the Delhi High Court in Smt. Harvinder Kaur v. Harmander Singh Choudhry, AIR 1984 Del 66. The decree is executed under Order XXI Rule 32 CPC, which in practice means attachment of property, not physical compulsion. A fresh challenge to Section 9 was entertained by the Supreme Court in 2019 (Ojaswa Pathak v. Union of India); please check its current status before relying on Saroj Rani in a pleading.
Does an RCR decree bar maintenance?
Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Rina Kumari @ Rina Devi @ Reena v. Dinesh Kumar Mahto @ Dinesh Kumar Mahato, 2025 INSC 55 (Crl. Appeal No. 161 of 2025, 10 January 2025, Sanjiv Khanna CJI and Sanjay Kumar, J.) has stated in para 29 that "the mere passing of a decree for restitution of conjugal rights at the husband's behest and non-compliance therewith by the wife would not, by itself, be sufficient to attract the disqualification under Section 125(4) Cr.P.C." The Court added that such a decree "would not be determinative straightaway either of her right to maintenance or the applicability of the disqualification", and that the question depends on whether the wife still had valid and sufficient reason to refuse to live with her husband.
The Court also rejected the argument that findings in the restitution decree bind the maintenance court (para 30 onwards), because maintenance proceedings are essentially civil in nature and independent of the Section 9 suit. The same disqualification now sits in Section 144 BNSS (earlier Section 125(4) CrPC).
On divorced wives, Rina Kumari (para 38) records Rohtash Singh v. Ramendri, (2000) 3 SCC 180, in which the Court "clarified that a wife, who suffered a decree of divorce on the ground of deserting her husband, would not be entitled to maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. as long as the marriage subsisted, but she would be entitled to such maintenance once she attained the status of a divorced wife".
Strategic use: execution and Section 13(1A)(ii)
In Rina Kumari (para 37) the Court observed that, having obtained the decree, the husband "neither sought execution of the decree under Order XXI Rule 32 CPC nor did he seek a decree of divorce under Section 13(1A)(ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955", and treated this as showing lack of bona fides. Section 13(1A)(ii) allows either party to seek divorce where there has been no restitution of conjugal rights for one year or upwards after the decree, subject to the bar in Section 23(1)(a) against taking advantage of one's own wrong.
Frequently asked questions
Can a husband defeat a maintenance claim by filing under Section 9?
Not by that alone. The maintenance court looks at whether the wife had sufficient reason to stay away.
Who must prove a reasonable excuse?
The spouse who withdrew from the society of the other.
Can the decree be enforced by arrest?
No. Order XXI Rule 32 CPC provides for attachment of property.
Can disobeying the decree lead to divorce?
After one year of non-restitution, either party may petition under Section 13(1A)(ii) HMA.
General legal information, not legal advice
Related reading:
Related services:
This article gives general information on the law and is not legal advice. It is not an advertisement or solicitation of work; the Bar Council of India does not permit advertisement or solicitation by advocates. Reading it does not create an advocate-client relationship. The law is stated as on 5 November 2026 and may change; please check the current position before relying on it.
Need legal help in Lucknow?
Speak with Advocate Shailender Singh.
Confidential, experienced representation before the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), Family Court and UP-RERA. Discuss your matter today.



